Where to Eat in Lancaster County: A Local Dining Guide for Guests of The Inn at Leola Village
Discover top-rated restaurants near The Inn at Leola Village in Lancaster County—from upscale Italian to steakhouses, pubs, rooftops & more
Lancaster County is known for its scenic beauty, vibrant arts scene, and charming towns—but it’s also home to a diverse and thriving culinary community. Whether you’re visiting The Inn at Leola Village for a romantic weekend, a relaxing retreat, or a destination wedding, you’ll find yourself surrounded by exceptional dining options.
From upscale steakhouses and historic taverns to speakeasies and rooftop lounges, here are our favorite highly rated restaurants to explore during your stay. And of course, no list would be complete without our own Osteria Avanti, a refined Italian experience tucked right here on our grounds.
Osteria Avanti – Leola, PA
Cuisine: Upscale Italian
Located within The Inn at Leola Village, Osteria Avanti offers an intimate, rustic-modern setting with a focus on housemade pastas, responsibly sourced meats, and local produce. The wine list is thoughtfully curated, and the service is warm and attentive—perfect for a romantic evening or celebratory dinner. It’s the kind of place that makes you want to linger a little longer.
John J. Jeffries – Lancaster City
Cuisine: Farm-to-Table American
Housed in the historic Lancaster Arts Hotel, John J. Jeffries is a pioneer in Lancaster’s farm-to-table movement. Their seasonally driven menus feature grass-fed meats, organic produce, and creative dishes that showcase local flavor with fine-dining finesse.
The Log Cabin – Leola, PA
Cuisine: Classic American Steakhouse
Just minutes from the Inn, The Log Cabin is a local landmark dating back to the 1920s. Known for its cozy ambiance and exceptional steaks, this is a go-to for guests celebrating something special or seeking a refined, lodge-style dining experience.
Bull’s Head Public House – Lititz, PA
Cuisine: British Pub
Named one of the best beer bars in America, Bull’s Head is an authentic British-style pub with an extensive beer list and hearty fare like fish and chips, shepherd’s pie, and bangers and mash. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, perfect for a casual evening out.
Bistro Barbaret & Bakery – Lancaster City
Cuisine: French Bistro & Pâtisserie
This downtown gem combines classic French cuisine with a chic, urban flair. Dine on duck confit, steak frites, or delicate seafood dishes—but be sure to save room for dessert. Their adjoining patisserie is renowned for artisan pastries, macarons, and seasonal specialties that are as beautiful as they are delicious.
Hi-Fi Izakaya – Lancaster City
Cuisine: Japanese Gastropub
A funky, high-energy spot inspired by Japanese izakayas, Hi-Fi offers small plates, ramen bowls, skewers, and sake in a music-forward setting. It's a favorite for adventurous diners looking to share a table full of bold, umami-packed flavors.
The Exchange – Lancaster City
Cuisine: New American & Craft Cocktails
Perched atop the Lancaster Marriott, The Exchange is a stylish rooftop bar and restaurant with panoramic views of the city skyline. Their rotating menu of small plates pairs beautifully with an extensive list of inventive cocktails, wines, and bourbons.
Proof – Lancaster City
Cuisine: Modern American & Whiskey Lounge
This sleek, intimate restaurant and bar is a must-visit for whiskey lovers. With an expertly curated spirits list and chef-driven menu, Proof delivers an upscale, moody vibe ideal for date nights or late-evening cocktails and bites.
401 Prime – Lancaster City
Cuisine: Contemporary Steakhouse
Lancaster’s newest luxury steakhouse, 401 Prime, offers dry-aged steaks, fresh seafood, and an elevated dining experience in a striking modern space. It’s a perfect pick for fine dining connoisseurs and celebratory dinners alike.
The Belvedere Inn – Lancaster City
Cuisine: Eclectic Fine Dining
Set in a beautifully restored Victorian mansion, The Belvedere offers an eclectic menu with global influences and an award-winning wine list. Known for its ambiance, jazz nights, and upstairs lounge, it's long been a favorite among locals and travelers alike.
Conway Social Club – Lancaster City
Cuisine: Speakeasy-Style Cocktails & Small Plates
Tucked discreetly above Annie Bailey's, Conway Social Club is a moody, intimate speakeasy offering handcrafted cocktails and globally inspired small plates. It's perfect for a stylish nightcap or pre-dinner rendezvous.
Southern Market – Lancaster City
Cuisine: Global Food Hall
For guests looking to try a little bit of everything, Southern Market offers a curated food hall experience in a beautifully restored historic building. From Korean fried chicken to gourmet tacos, wood-fired pizza, and artisan gelato, the rotating vendor stalls offer something for every palate. It’s a great option for groups or casual lunches with flair.
Whether you’re craving a rustic steakhouse, a cozy pub, rooftop cocktails, or refined Italian, Lancaster County offers a rich dining landscape to explore during your stay. Ask our concierge for recommendations or reservations—we’re happy to help you make the most of every bite.
Book your getaway at The Inn at Leola Village and savor the flavors of Lancaster, one unforgettable meal at a time.
Other Articles you may like
Nestled in the heart of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, lies a hidden gem waiting to be explored: The Inn at Leola Village. Surrounded by the serene beauty of Amish farmlands and rich with history, this quaint inn offers more than just a place to stay—it offers an immersive experience into the fascinating world of the Amish.
